I think this is a VERY difficult question EVERY day. I read EVERYONE's picks, I respect the heck out of the work everyone does. NOW........this is going to be EXTREMELY controversial., BUT I will say it::
I LOVE the cappers that go out of the box and fire away on derivatives/team totals/etc. So Shaker is a must read every morning. I also LOVE the guys who fire EARLY to beat line moves, and fire LATE (even if it costs them sales) to get the best of the number (The best example would be Tulsa -5 or Tulane +7-115 plays). I love cappers that have made me tons of money over the years (Smokin Cokin HELLO!)
I am NOT so fond of the cappers that put up the "happy action fun time" plays like CFB teasers, non correlated parlays of the month, and ML parlays. I'm not saying you will lose playing someone's CFB teasers,BUT over any large sample if you DO win playing them you will win MORE betting each play ATS (the books just rip you off completely on CFB teasers they should pay at +110 or more, it's a very very hard game,). I'd buy Ken THomson since
1) He hasn't sold ANYTHING all summer, getting ready for CFB AND
2) HE USED to play CFB teasers and actually listened to me and now does not.
If I had to bet someone's stuff blind, I'd probably go Smash Mouth with Scott..........even with a spread team!
So very unclear who to go with. I have to go now, as I need to sign up for Gomes NBA REGULAR SEASON annual service! NOw, THAT is an ez one