jeff232323,
The archive shows picks for any games played that day. If a Pro didn't have any picks for that day, none show for that day.
One more time ... every pick from every Pro ever is graded, archived, and available for review. In the By-Date archive, it's as simple as picking the date you want to see (though obviously if there were no picks that day, no picks are displayed).
Here's an example date with picks from Sept (simply click the SHOW PICKS button)
pregame.com/.../archivedpicks.aspx;dt=11/08/15
Hopefully you now understand the truth, and how you were wrong before.