Rogers was overrated without question from the beginning - the super bowl run against Vick, Ryan, and Cutler, was when the NFC was at hte weakest point. Detroit Minnesota have also been garbage during most of his career with the Bears not much better. He also had donald driver, greg jennings, and jordy nelson, with a strong offensive line. Defense constantly gave him short field position as well. McCarthy has made Aaron Brooks and Matt Flynn look great, Seattle even gave Matt Flynn big money he looked so good in McCarthy's system. Rodgers without elite receivers agains good defense was mediocre even in his prime - look at game against San Francisco, Seattle, Giantsss