I debated this at the first of the season. I stated he would be their demise and was not ready to be a starter. So far he has proven me right, not to my surprise.
He DOES have major issues comprehending and understanding defense's in the NFL, and throws into coverage, floats balls into gaps in 2 deep coverage, cannot get play calls right when he checks out of a play, and is not comfy in the pocket by any stretch.
Thought his best showing was against Chicago on MNF and he still sucked and they got waxed. Vick is the only way to look. Smith - Good College QB, below average NFL QB....bottom line. Gonna cost Rex Ryan his job by seasons end....