Shedeur Sanders vs. Tyler Shough: Who Will Have the Better NFL Career?
The 2025 NFL Draft offered no shortage of surprises, but perhaps none more intriguing than the divergent fates of two standout quarterbacks: Shedeur Sanders and Tyler Shough. Once viewed as a potential first-rounder, Sanders saw his stock drop, while Shough capitalized on a strong final college season to secure a second-round selection. Their unique journeys and skillsets now fuel debate over which quarterback will emerge with the better NFL career.
College Careers in Contrast
Tyler Shough: The Journeyman Veteran
Tyler Shough’s path to the NFL was anything but linear. Playing across three major programs—Oregon, Texas Tech, and Louisville—Shough amassed over 10,000 passing yards and more than 75 touchdowns. His final season with Louisville saw him throw for 3,195 yards and 23 touchdowns, showcasing his deep-ball accuracy and toughness.
Standing at 6'5" and 225 pounds, Shough fits the prototypical NFL quarterback mold. However, his long collegiate tenure and history of injuries raise concerns about his long-term durability. Still, his resilience and maturity have made him an appealing prospect, particularly for teams looking for a quick contributor.
Shedeur Sanders: The High-IQ Technician
Shedeur Sanders, son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, brought flair and statistical brilliance to both Jackson State and Colorado. In four seasons, he passed for over 14,000 yards and 134 touchdowns. His 2024 campaign was particularly impressive: 4,134 yards, 37 touchdowns, and just 10 interceptions.
Despite these numbers, Sanders dropped to the 5th round—144th overall—due to reportedly poor interviews and concerns about his attitude. While his mechanics and football IQ were never in question, some teams were wary of his maturity and coachability. That said, his pocket presence and accuracy make him one of the most talented quarterbacks in the class.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Attribute |
Tyler Shough |
Shedeur Sanders |
| Draft Position |
2nd Round, 40th Overall |
5th Round, 144th Overall |
| Height/Weight |
6'5" / 225 lbs |
6'2" / 215 lbs |
| College Yards |
10,000+ |
14,000+ |
| 2024 Stats |
3,195 Yds / 23 TDs / 6 INTs |
4,134 Yds / 37 TDs / 10 INTs |
| Strengths |
Size, Arm Strength, Resilience |
Accuracy, IQ, Pocket Presence |
| Concerns |
Injuries, Age (26) |
Maturity, Draft Interviews |
Team Fit and Opportunity
New Orleans Saints – Tyler Shough
Selected by the Saints with the 40th pick, Shough lands in a favorable situation. With an aging quarterback room and no locked-in starter, he has a legitimate chance to compete early. The Saints’ offensive scheme, which favors vertical passing, aligns well with his strengths.
Cleveland Browns – Shedeur Sanders
Drafted 144th overall, Sanders enters a less defined path in Cleveland. Competing with Dillon Gabriel and veteran depth, he may start his career buried on the depth chart. However, the Browns’ history of quarterback instability could open doors if he stays ready and proves his value in practice.
Career Trajectories
Short-Term Advantage: Tyler Shough
With a higher draft slot and immediate team need, Shough is likely to see the field sooner. His physical traits and experience make him a safer early bet.
Long-Term Upside: Shedeur Sanders
If Sanders matures and adapts to the pro game, his ceiling may be higher. His arm talent, vision, and accuracy give him the tools to exceed expectations—especially if placed in a system that plays to his strengths.
Final Verdict
In the early years, Tyler Shough may win the playing time battle due to draft capital and readiness. But long-term, Shedeur Sanders remains a wildcard with elite upside. If his development stays on track and off-field concerns fade, he could ultimately emerge as the more impactful NFL quarterback.