I want to caveat this one, I don't have the numbers, if I did I think I would just blindly recommend whoever won the most units over the last five years in the NFL and CFB. I am a huge believer in getting behind the guy who has the best documented win rate, period. Further, I don't differentiate regular season and playoffs:
NFL:
We have MANY outstanding Cappers that you would be in good hands with. I would go with Stephen Nover. NFL is the sports he originates the most, he knows the players, he is a fantasy sports guru, he has a tremendous LONG TERM track record of winning in the NFL. In 2016 he already has five plays up, this shows me he is dialed in and focused on NFL already, a very good sign. The Man LOSES HIS MIND when he loses a micro Fantasy Football NFL League. That's the competitive spirit I look for in a capper.
CFB:
Lots of great choices. I think if I have to go with one, hard to argue with the Man with the big Hat, Shake the money off the tree Greg Shaker simply due to his long term wnning track record, and great 2015 CFB.
However, I want Ken Thomson's plays in CFB and CBB badly. Ralph Michaels gave me a CFB early play that moved a TD, do that and you get my attention DAMN fast. All GoodFella and Dave Essler do is win win win it seems. If you are a salary cap expert, Sleepy is a must pick up, solid analysis, a winner, and knows this Shit. Dave Cokin made me THE MOST over the years, back in 2000 I would listen to him on the Stardust line give out 3 best bets on the openers and go 2-1 seemingly every week, so I have a long term bias there. Damn it, I don't want to miss out on any Spartan big releases, and Merrill went 18-0 this summer, and Iskoe won a zillion units in 2015, and hell, just give me all them and the rest of our crack cappers also......
PLAYOFFS: I would switch to the guy that won THE MOST during the regular season. PERIOD.