Forums

Forums
Where sports bettors talk!

Topic of the Day: Most overrated athletes of all time?

NBA
Thread Starter Topic of the Day: Most overrated athletes of all time?
Johnny Detroit
Joined: 06/21/2006
Posts: 20844
All Pro
Top 10 Contributor

Yesterday's Topic of the Day: Most exciting sports moment seen LIVE?



You seem to always see the debates about Lebron vs Kobe, 80's vs 90's or Brady vs Manning. These arguments take the best of the best and end up in a pretty good discussion. For today's topic, how about we look at the worst of the best. You know, those athletes that go down in history as a "great" but maybe do not deserve that tag. I will start it off with two of mine:

Mike Tyson: Sure he was exciting to watch as he destroyed opponents in the matter of minutes. Who could forgot the one punch knock outs of the helpless Little Mac. Tyson is easily one of the most overrated athletes in history. One dimensional slugger who beat up has-beens from the 70's and bums for the 80's. Name ONE GOOD fighter he ever beat? His fight with Ruddock went to a rematch, while Lennox Lewis knocked him (Ruddock) out cold through the ropes in the 1st round. He lost to Buster Douglas and was dominated by Evander as a huge favorite. McNeely? Seldon? 68 year old Spinx? Slow as molasses Frank Bruno? He fought in probably one of the worst eras in boxing history. 

Some will argue Joe Namath could be the most overrated player in the history of the NFL. Flashy coats, snappy interviews and the Super Bowl is what made "Broadway Joe". His overall career stats: 

Barely a 50% career completion percentage (7 of his 13 years were below 50%)
173 TDs
220 INTs

Hall of Famer? Yeah, yeah, I know the whole first to toss for 4000 yards thing but does that change his actual numbers?

Help me out, who am I missing?

57% Over 800+ NFL/CFB Wagers Since 2004!

Follow JD on twitter CLICK HERE Follow JD on Facebook CLICK HERE Follow JD on Google+ CLICK HERE Follow JD on Tumblr CLICK HERE

Johnny Detroit, Co-Founder and Vice-President Bettors get ready at Pregame.com
1-800-PREGAME | johnny@pregame.com AOL/YAHOO IM: johnnypregame MSN Messenger: jd@pregame.com

ConorB
Joined: 10/18/2011
Posts: 2876
All Pro
Top 150 Contributor

David Beckham by far

Vegasbaby
Joined: 01/09/2010
Posts: 677
All American
Not Ranked

Any baseball player from the mid 80's - mid 90's such as Jose Canseco, Brady Anderson, Lenny Dykstra, Alex Rodriguez, BARRY BONDS etc etc all on the juice all had inflated numbers do to taking roids.

Griff
Joined: 08/20/2009
Posts: 19059
All Pro
Top 10 Contributor

Jamarcus Russel out of LSU to Raiders

"EVERY DOG HAS HIS DAY"

Navin R Johnsun
Joined: 10/04/2010
Posts: 1460
Professional
Top 500 Contributor

David Klingler, Akili Smith, Brian Bosworth in NFL.

I also think Lebron is so overated but I dont want to start that.

russemar
Joined: 01/30/2011
Posts: 4946
All Pro
Top 100 Contributor

2 former Heisman trophy winners.Archie Griffin won the damn thing twice and did squat in the NFL and Herschel Walker took the USFL 'S money and ran and then was just mediocre at best in the NFL.

2012  NFL  33-29 (+13.55 units)

2012  CFB  34-35 (+6.90 units)

2012-2013 CBB  271-220-16 (+71.10 units)

2012-2013  NBA  4-5-1  (-4.20 units)

c_lemm
Joined: 11/08/2011
Posts: 5
Waterboy
Not Ranked

Emmit smith... Ran behind one of the best o lines in the history of the NFL.

Griff
Joined: 08/20/2009
Posts: 19059
All Pro
Top 10 Contributor

Bet the Chargers would say Ryan Leaf

"EVERY DOG HAS HIS DAY"

Griff
Joined: 08/20/2009
Posts: 19059
All Pro
Top 10 Contributor

Bet the Chargers would say Ryan Leaf

"EVERY DOG HAS HIS DAY"

Navin R Johnsun
Joined: 10/04/2010
Posts: 1460
Professional
Top 500 Contributor

I forgot jailbirds Lawrence Phillips and Maurice Clarrett.

  • 39 Replies
  • 11 Subscribers
  • Postedover 1 year ago