May want to tred carefully here Dave. I'm no fan of McCarthy and his numbers (3-10 with a 5.01 ERA) look hideous. But he has a respectable ground ball and strikeout rate. He's won his last two games giving up three runs in 12 2/3 innings, he's been away from the AL for two seasons and will be highly motivated to pitch well in his Yankee debut.
Tomlin has allowed five earned runs in three of his last four starts only once reaching the seventh inning during this span.
I'm not recommending the Yankees, but I'm going to stay away from the Indians. BOL to you.